Choosing redaction software: ten questions to compare anonymisation software
There is more and more software to redact and anonymise documents. Which one fits best depends on your organisation. With these ten questions you compare vendors on what really matters. Each question includes Verilak's answer, so you know where we stand.
Ten questions for every vendor
Is the text under the redaction really gone?
Ask whether the text is removed from the file or only covered. Test it yourself: select and copy the text under a redaction and search for the redacted name.
Verilak: a redacted page becomes an image, then a separate check searches the file for any remaining trace of the text.
Do the documents go to the cloud?
With a cloud service the documents leave your organisation. That calls for a data processing agreement, a DPIA on that processing and trust in the vendor.
Verilak: runs fully offline on the workstation, without an account. We never see your documents.
Who decides what is redacted?
Automatic recognition misses things and sometimes mistakes something for personal data. The Woo and the GDPR call for review by a person.
Verilak: makes proposals, the staff member decides. Nothing is redacted without review.
How does the recognition work?
Ask whether the software uses fixed rules or a trained model and what the known error margins are. A Dutch public body has to be able to describe that in the Algorithm register.
Verilak: recognition in text works with fixed rules, with the eleven test for the citizen service number and the check digits for the IBAN. There is a description of every detector for the Algorithm register.
Does it support the Woo?
Think of a legal ground per redaction, an inventory list and consistent redaction across a whole case file.
Verilak: all three, plus merging with page numbers and publishing as PDF/A.
Does the metadata go as well?
A well redacted document with the author's name in its properties is not anonymous.
Verilak: removes the author, comments, tracked changes, GPS location and other hidden metadata.
Which files can it handle?
Woo case files consist of PDFs, Word documents, spreadsheets, scans and photos.
Verilak: redacts PDFs, Office files, scans (with text recognition) and photos. See also the file types.
Is it accessible?
Software for the public sector has to meet the accessibility requirements, also for staff using a screen reader.
Verilak: WCAG 2.1 level AA, fully keyboard operable, and output as accessible PDF/UA.
How is it rolled out and managed?
Ask about an installer, central policy and what the administrator has to do.
Verilak: an MSI package and policy templates for Microsoft Intune. No server needed.
What does it cost, also in three years?
Watch out for prices per user, per page or per document: they rise as use grows. Also ask about costs for set up and support.
Verilak: a fixed yearly price per organisation, from €495, with unlimited users and documents. See Pricing.
Find the best anonymisation software with your own documents
A demo with sample documents says little. Compare the best anonymisation software for your organisation with a real case file: how much does the software find, how much do you still have to do yourself, and is there really nothing left under the black boxes after redaction? How to check that last point is explained on A black bar, but the text is still there.
Working for a municipality, water board or province? Then also read Redaction software for government.
Put Verilak next to your current way of working?
In a free six week pilot you test Verilak with your own case files, on your own workstations.