Woo refusal grounds: what you redact and on which ground
In a decision under the Dutch Open Government Act (Woo) you have to be able to explain for every redacted passage why it is not disclosed. The Woo lists the refusal grounds for that in articles 5.1 and 5.2. Here you read them in plain language, with examples of what you redact in practice, and how Verilak puts the ground on every redaction.
How do you read a ground such as 5.1.2e?
On a redaction the ground is usually shown as a short code. 5.1.2e means article 5.1, second paragraph, under e: respect for privacy. 5.1.1e is article 5.1, first paragraph, under e: identification numbers such as the citizen service number (BSN). The reader of the decision sees at every black box why the text is missing.
The Woo has two kinds of grounds. With the absolute grounds in the first paragraph, disclosure is withheld as soon as the ground applies. With the relative grounds in the second paragraph you weigh the interest of disclosure against the interest the ground protects. If you refuse on a relative ground, the law requires an explicit reasoning in the decision.
Absolute refusal grounds (article 5.1, first paragraph)
| Code | Ground | What you redact, for example |
|---|---|---|
| 5.1.1a | The unity of the Crown | Rarely applies |
| 5.1.1b | The security of the State | Information about state secrets or intelligence |
| 5.1.1c | Business and manufacturing data supplied to the government in confidence | Sensitive figures from a grant application |
| 5.1.1d | Special categories of personal data and criminal data, unless the person consented or made them public | Health, religion, ethnic origin, a criminal record |
| 5.1.1e | Statutory identification numbers, unless disclosure clearly does not infringe privacy | Citizen service number (BSN) |
Relative refusal grounds (article 5.1, second paragraph)
| Code | Ground | What you redact, for example |
|---|---|---|
| 5.1.2a | Relations with other countries and international organisations | Confidential diplomatic contacts |
| 5.1.2b | Economic or financial interests of the government | Room for negotiation in a land purchase |
| 5.1.2c | Investigation and prosecution of criminal offences | Details of an ongoing investigation |
| 5.1.2d | Inspection, control and supervision | Methods and planning of inspections |
| 5.1.2e | Respect for privacy | Names, addresses, phone numbers and email addresses of citizens and staff, signatures |
| 5.1.2f | Other competition sensitive business and manufacturing data | Prices and margins from a quotation |
| 5.1.2g | Protection of the environment | The location of a protected species |
| 5.1.2h | Security of persons and companies and prevention of sabotage | Access codes, floor plans of secured rooms |
| 5.1.2i | The proper functioning of the government | Information that would disproportionately hinder the work of an administrative body |
In exceptional cases disclosure can also be withheld because of disproportionate harm to another interest (article 5.1, fifth paragraph). You do not use that ground together with a ground from the first or second paragraph for the same information.
Personal policy views (article 5.2)
Personal policy views are not disclosed from documents for internal deliberation: officials' advice, views, positions and considerations. Facts, forecasts, policy alternatives and other parts of a predominantly objective nature do not fall under this; they remain public.
The administrative body may still disclose such views in a form that cannot be traced back to persons, in the interest of good and democratic governance. You then mainly redact the names of those who gave the view.
Black or white redaction?
Both make text or images unreadable before you publish a document. Some organisations redact in white, so the document looks calmer. The reader then sees less clearly where something is missing.
Verilak redacts in black and prints the ground on the box. That way every passage shows that something was withheld and on which ground, in line with the reasoning the Woo asks for.
How Verilak records the ground
On the box
For every redaction you choose the ground from the list with all grounds of articles 5.1 and 5.2. The code is shown on the black box.
Filled in for you
For a BSN Verilak proposes 5.1.1e, for a name or address 5.1.2e. You can change the ground per box.
In the inventory list
For each document the Woo inventory list shows what was redacted and on which ground.
In the audit log
Every decision goes into an audit log that cannot be changed unnoticed, so you can account afterwards for who decided what.
This explanation is a simplification. The text of the Woo is leading, and whether a ground applies is assessed case by case.
Redaction with the ground on every box
Try Verilak free for six weeks with your own Woo case files.